On November 8, Vitalik Buterin (@VitalikButerin) published a long post on X revisiting where ETH’s value comes from. A report published on November 11, 2026, at 20:30 UTC+8, summarized that argument and compared how several major networks issue and burn native tokens. What follows stays with that report and does not treat the discussion as a new development after that date.
For years, Ethereum carried an “ultrasound money” narrative: active applications would raise gas use, and ongoing fee burns could offset issuance and even make ETH deflationary. Buterin argued that fee destruction was never a reliable valuation floor. Much of the earlier fee revenue, he said, came from speculative activity inside crypto markets, so burn income would shrink if those markets declined.
He still supported keeping EIP-1559. Even if burns stayed below 10% of new issuance for a long time, he said that would not be a reason for regret. Deliberately pushing fees higher only to keep burns large could, in his view, harm Ethereum’s decentralization and long-term development.
The report then asks a wider question: if “more applications, more burns, a more valuable token” is no longer dependable, what is supposed to support the valuation of a public-chain token that continues to be issued?
Issuance and burns are not one model
Most proof-of-stake chains, the report notes, issue tokens to reward validators and reduce supply by burning fees. Different rules produce different supply paths. The figures below are those given in the November 11 report.
Bitcoin. Supply is capped at about 21 million, with a halving every four years and a falling inflation rate. The block reward was 3.125 BTC. At an average of one block every ten minutes, annual new supply was put at about 164,300 BTC, or about 0.82% annualized inflation.
Ether. New issuance fell sharply after The Merge in 2022, and cumulative supply growth since the Merge was about 1.37%. EIP-1559 burns the entire base fee. With wider layer-2 use and lower gas costs, burns over the most recent 30 days offset only about 3.2% of new issuance. Supply growth, very low since the Merge, had recently accelerated again, and the older deflation story was under strain.
Solana. SOL keeps being issued, but the inflation rate is set to decline. The initial annual rate was 8%, falling 15% a year toward a long-term target of 1.5%. During the 2024 meme surge, daily burns at one point exceeded 10,000 SOL. In January 2025, burns offset about 23% of new issuance. After SIMD-0096, priority fees go entirely to validators and only 50% of the base fee is burned. Daily burns later fell at one point to about 700 SOL.
BNB. BNB is not kept in continuous issuance. Supply is reduced by a quarterly Auto-Burn and by real-time gas burns under BEP-95, with a target total of 100 million. The first four quarterly burns of 2026 destroyed about 6.2 million BNB. Auto-Burn sets the amount from price and blocks produced; BEP-95 burns a portion of network fees.
TRX. TRON issues TRX through block rewards and burns Energy and Bandwidth fees that users pay. Users can also obtain those resources by staking or renting. The report’s point is that higher USDT transfer volume does not necessarily mean TRX burns rise in step.
AVAX. The cap is 720 million. New issuance rewards validators, while fees on the X, C and P chains are fully burned. As of early November 2026, about 474 million AVAX had been minted, including about 114 million in staking rewards, while cumulative burns were about 5.18 million—still not enough to offset new issuance.
SUI. Total supply is fixed at 10 billion. Circulating supply mainly rises through unlocks rather than unlimited issuance. A Storage Fund locks part of storage fees and compensates validators through staking yield. Deleting data returns most of the fee; the unreturned share stays in the fund and reduces freely circulating supply, but it is not a permanent burn.
A burn formula the post called unreliable
Buterin reviewed a once-popular model: token valuation equals annual burn value divided by a discount rate. Under that formula, a chain that steadily burned $1 billion of tokens a year, at a 4% discount rate, would have a theoretical value of about $25 billion.
He argued that this supposed floor is not reliable. For ETH, the report cites about 1.48 million ETH burned in 2022, worth about $3.6 billion. From the start of 2026 through November 8, cumulative burns were only about 19,200 ETH, worth about $43 million. Simply annualizing that year’s burn amount to about $50 million, at the same discount rate, produced a theoretical value of about $1.25 billion. Over the same period, ETH’s market capitalization was about $270 billion—a gap of more than 200 times. In the account given, that gap shows the model’s limits; it is not presented as a price target.
The report frames similar problems for other chains:
- Fee income is unstable. Large earlier burns were tied mainly to speculative activity such as NFTs and fell as markets cooled, so they are hard to treat as a long-term stable cash flow.
- Burning is only one way value is distributed. On Solana, priority fees go to validators. On TRON, resource rents can become income for stakers. That economic value does not all appear as tokens destroyed.
On this account, burn totals can measure part of value capture, but they do not provide one valuation standard for every public chain.
What else the post put forward
If fee burns cannot anchor valuation, the report asks where ETH’s longer-term value might still come from. Buterin put more weight on decentralization, censorship resistance, open source, privacy and security. He specifically said that, in a period of rapid AI development, a system able to keep running without control by a single party could become more precious.
The same write-up records skepticism rather than a settled answer:
- ETH already had a market capitalization in the hundreds of billions of dollars, which fee revenue alone does not explain. Demand for it as on-chain collateral, a medium of exchange and the native asset of financial infrastructure could itself create a monetary premium.
- ETH has no fixed supply cap, and issuance rules can be changed through protocol upgrades. Competing with Bitcoin as a store of value would still require a reason why ETH should receive the same long-term trust on supply rules and monetary policy.
Burns can at least be counted. A monetary premium from store-of-value demand does not come with one agreed yardstick. Narratives can change, the report says, but the market still needs a reason people would hold ETH for the long term.
Questions the comparison leaves open
For several years, crypto projects pursued higher volume, lower fees and busier on-chain activity. As fees fall and burns struggle to underwrite valuations, the report says public chains are rethinking where native-token value comes from. Buterin’s renewed attention to store of value, it suggests, may indicate a shift in that logic.
It does not claim the shift is decided. It asks whether, as more chains emphasize scarcity, security and long-term consensus, markets will actually pay a monetary premium comparable to Bitcoin’s. It also asks what a native token can rely on if application scale later grows tenfold while fee revenue keeps falling.
Those remain questions in the source, not forecasts or a case for any transaction.
Source: odaily.news (originally published 2026-11-11 20:30 UTC+8)




